Our look at the fantasy football magazines taking over your newsstand like so much ivy continues with another well-known brand.
Sporting News Fantasy Football
Vital stats: $7.99, 148 pages with a 2-page pullout sheet, 397 offensive players (294 ranked) and 170 defensive players (105 ranked) previewed.
Top 10 picks: If you are playing in the typical 10-team league, the Sporting News has put your draft’s first round right on its cover. It says you should take Chris Johnson, Adrian Peterson, Maurice Jones-Drew, Ray Rice, Michael Turner, Steven Jackson, Andre Johnson, DeAngelo Williams, Drew Brees and Frank Gore.
Well, maybe not: The Sporting News “experts” held a 12-team draft, and they forgot to read their own cover. Two of the top 10 draft choices were used on Aaron Rodgers (a slight surprise, but nothing more) and Shonn Greene (a legitimate jaw-dropper).
Intriguing nugget: Like many fantasy football magazines, this one offers a peek at each team’s schedule. Unlike most magazines, this one highlights the games that are likely to occur during your league’s playoffs. For example, in weeks 14-16, the Dallas Cowboys face three teams (Philadelphia, Washington and Arizona) that “finished in the top nine in sacks last season.”
Head scratcher: These folks tell us this about the notion of paying attention to preseason hype: “We can almost throw this one out without thinking about it.” But then, what does that make this magazine?
Kicker rule obeyed? To quote Judd Nelson from “The Breakfast Club,” not even close, bud. In the 12-team draft of Sporting News experts, four picked a kicker before the last round. The magazine’s assessment? “Eight of the final 12 picks in the draft were kickers, which is how it should be.” That’s right; fantasy football rules should be followed only two-thirds of the time.
Listen up: While everyone else is all worked up about a certain quarterback who, as of this writing, has neither reported for training camp nor filed retirement papers with the NFL, this magazine does a good job of informing fantasy football players about the very real possibility that we will have no football in the 2011 season.
Two options that are raised (and dashed quickly) are fantasy CFL and fantasy college football. “Tyler Sheehan, Donald Buckram, James Cleveland? These aren’t congressmen running for re-election; they’re the No. 3 passer, No. 6 runner and No. 8 receiver, respectively, in college football last season.”
We’ll be back with a look at this week’s NASCAR site.
The People's Pigskin 
Lovely! Very well-done! 🙂
Comment by good bmx bikes — August 28, 2010 @ 1:37 am
It’s a breath of large knowledge. I’m grateful for this excellent addition.
Comment by Pablo Brammer — November 29, 2010 @ 3:36 am
[…] bad source? In this post, we look back at the predictions offered by four preseason fantasy preview magazines and consider whether they did any better than you would have fared picking your team this way. […]
Pingback by Reviewing the Previews (Again) « The People's Pigskin — January 4, 2011 @ 11:26 am